论坛风格切换
  • 4823阅读
  • 14回复

shoutfactory美国一区【头领战士】DVD套装 测评 [复制链接]

上一主题 下一主题
离线罗索
 

发帖
1247
能量块
4951790
经验值
31610
贡献值
135
交易币
0
只看楼主 倒序阅读 使用道具 0 发表于: 2011-07-10
shoutfactory公司于2011年7月15日发售 头领战士 4DVD套装,以下为国外迷测评。 英文不佳,只能让各位看英文了。


Although new G1 Transformers episodes stopped airing in the US after 1987, most TF fans know that they soldiered on in Japan for another 3yrs.  Three series were created in that time, and they were vastly different from how the US saw Transformers.  For most fans, there have only been two methods of seeing these Japanese episodes.  Either you watched the Malaysian RTM-1 redubs on VCD or you caught fansubs on YouTube.  Both methods felt like something was missing.  Shout Factory finally introduces the conduit needed to bring a production quality version of these shows to the US.  Their first release is Headmasters.


For anyone who is familiar with the Headmaster series, you can skip this part.  For those who are NOT, some brief history is in order.  Headmasters attempts to segue events of Season 3 into a Japanese flavored continuum.  That being said, you may be confused by some of the events (such as Prowl appearing in the first episode or the events taking place 'one year later' in 2011).  Season 3 in the US was known as Transformers 2010 in Japan.  Some of the translations there did not follow the dialogue of Season 3, hence some differences.


Headmasters comes in a 4-DVD set contained in a single case.  Each DVD has an outline drawing of one of the 4 Autobot Headmasters.  The Japanese Headmasters title is also plastered all over the place. The sleeve features an episode list on the left side, with the outline drawing of the case cover on the right.  Very nicely done overall.



All 35 Headmaster episodes are represented in this set.  This covers the time from  the Vector Sigma assaults on Cybertron to the final battle in the North Pole.  For anyone wondering about video quality, there is no remastering done here.  All the episodes are in analog broadcast quality.  This is just as well, since many of us know how Rhino's remastering attempts went with the original G1 boxed sets.  One small gripe is that all the bumpers have been removed.  It might have made for a nice bonus feature.



Speaking of bonus features, the only one you get are some line drawings of the main characters.  This feature can be found on Disc 4.  Line drawings for all the Headmasters, Targetmasters, Horrorcons and Sixshot can be found there.  That's all you get.





The RTM-1 and fansubs always made you think you were missing part of the translation.  It's evident that Hasbro and Shout Factory took some strides to make characters familiar to US fans while trying to keep integrity to the Japanese versions.  On the plus side, the translations by Shout Factory make the most sense out of any I've seen and keep the show on mostly a serious plane.  While the humor is still very evident, the dialogue makes much more sense.



There were also liberties taken.  A lot of battle dialogue was mellowed down.  References to Hell were completely omitted, for instance.  Funny thing is, in at least one instance the word DAMN was still used.  Also, while the translations are excellent in quality, the subtitling was not.  Several grammatical and spelling errors were encountered just on Disc 1.  You would think the text would have been more closely proofread.  Finally, some of the character names were westernized.  Fortress in his robot mode is referred to as Cerebros, even as the characters in voice refer to him as Fortress.  This was Hasbro's attempt to not confuse the US audience, but they might end up confused anyhow.




Transformers The Japanese Collection: Headmasters won't be sitting on the shelf at your favorite Best Buy, Target or Walmart.  Shout Factory offers the 4-DVD collection for $24.98 That's not bad for 4 DVDs and breaks it down to about 71 cents an episode.  If you have the VCD copies that were so proliferate on eBay, it's worth considering.  The video quality will be better and you won't be forced to download Real Player to watch them.  For those who view it on Youtube, it's also worth considering.  The subtitles are well done (even with the typing mistakes) and, again, the video quality is slightly better.   You might not get a digital remastering with a ton of special features, but you will get to own a part of G1 that, until now, the US as a whole never got a chance to view.







                          
离线rogerdry

发帖
1317
能量块
118234
经验值
12733
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 1 发表于: 2011-07-10
封面很日式,哈哈
TF的乐趣在于分享
离线幻影FQI

发帖
12144
能量块
1891772
经验值
276931
贡献值
135
交易币
0
只看该作者 2 发表于: 2011-07-10
头领两大主角,其实就是合金盾和六面兽。
我隐藏在敌人中的某一处……
离线power500

发帖
144
能量块
4935
经验值
1291
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 3 发表于: 2011-07-10
美國連頭領戰士都出了DVD , 下次會不會出超神力量= =

发帖
146
能量块
4900
经验值
691
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 4 发表于: 2011-07-10

这是个残酷的结局
离线hemaliang

发帖
88
能量块
2575
经验值
455
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 5 发表于: 2011-07-10
哦......这个意思
离线lstzdw

发帖
76
能量块
1000
经验值
279
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 6 发表于: 2011-07-10
顶头领战士,期待
http://shop57614384.taobao.com
离线bshun

发帖
34
能量块
608
经验值
449
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 7 发表于: 2011-07-10
貌似是日语+英文字幕
离线shuihuxian

发帖
28
能量块
615
经验值
114
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 8 发表于: 2011-07-11
瞅着心里就爽。
离线暗黑血统

发帖
317
能量块
24590
经验值
2737
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 9 发表于: 2011-07-11
配音是英文的吧.......?
不要那蛋疼的日语....!像武士道精神....
离线威震天

发帖
250
能量块
21966
经验值
20805
贡献值
12
交易币
0
只看该作者 10 发表于: 2011-07-11
合金盾是谁?

不要让时间的铁锉磨平我们战士的锋芒
不要让生活的安逸冷却我们战士的热血

邪恶与正义共生
黑暗和光明并存
离线双侠

发帖
817
能量块
30018
经验值
8961
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 11 发表于: 2011-07-11
引用第10楼威震天于2011-07-11 10:54发表的  :
[表情] 合金盾是谁?

Chromedome.
离线bshun

发帖
34
能量块
608
经验值
449
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 12 发表于: 2011-07-11
引用第9楼暗黑血统于2011-07-11 09:13发表的  :
配音是英文的吧.......?
不要那蛋疼的日语....!像武士道精神....

这玩意儿原本就是日本人搞的,美国人只搞了G1的最后的三话“重生”
那个才叫蛋疼吧
离线wanenjie

发帖
4
能量块
140
经验值
30
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 13 发表于: 2011-07-16
几时可以下载啊?
离线johnson0618

发帖
34
能量块
1250
经验值
128
贡献值
0
交易币
0
只看该作者 14 发表于: 2011-07-18
这个6面兽到底是善还是恶啊,这个DVD版有下载链接吗
快速回复
限120 字节
 
上一个 下一个