[提问]请教大家一个问题, [复制链接]

在大电影中看到千斤顶重伤躺在那，后来一直到Ｇ１结束也没见他出来过，请问他是不是死了呢？？

美版：确认死亡，没说的。
日版：胜利之斗争中和米诺娃、感知器组成医疗小组救助重伤的超神迅雷，展开“胜利计划”。由于日本没有及时上映电影版，所以日本的编剧也搞不清楚谁死了谁没死。于是千斤顶又出现了。

受伤后难道不能恢复吗？

31 回复：变形金刚档案库-----最伤感的一幕☆ 汽车人陵墓 ☆ 
分析：千斤顶是第一代变形金刚故事中最重要的几位配角人物之一，尽管没有自己的主角剧情，却有着很多的描写。 他是所有变形金刚故事所登场的第一个角色（第一天）登场也贯穿了G1全剧的始终（胜利之斗争）他的有趣发明更是引出众多精彩故事（静止器）（在好莱坞拍电影）无论在美国还是日本的迷友看来，千斤顶都是一个大众情人式的人气角色。



花絮：千斤顶是G1历史上最有争议的人物，争论的焦点在于其的生死。美版故事曾设定其死于变形金刚电影版中。但日版故事中其并为死亡，对此最为合理的解释是：因为电影版错误众多，和美版自己的2010故事都有颇多出入， 因此依旧以日版设定为准。事实上，在2002年推出的G1PVC系列中，千斤顶的模型被归入胜利斗争系列中发行，事实上是官方的承认了其未死亡的论证。此争论也销声匿迹。 

 
作者： 218.3.163.*  2004-12-19 19:35 　 回复此发言   

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

32 回复：变形金刚档案库-----最伤感的一幕☆ 汽车人陵墓 ☆ 
综上所述,又翻阅了一下变形金刚英文网站,美方也认定千斤顶最后并没有死!!!!!日版干的最大好事,就是让千斤顶,这样一位很有个性和人气的角色复活,而且在美国(尽管美国人也不欣赏日版的剧集)也已经被公认!!!!! 
====================================================
转来的网友讨论...

Wheeljack made an appearance in 1989, in the later series Transformers: Victory in Japan. Wheeljack, along with Perceptor and Minerva were called upon to save God Ginrai, who they converted into Victory Leo. The general explanation for this error (and similar ones perpetrated with other characters in the earlier series, Transformers: Headmasters) is that the Japanese animators and writers were not fully aware of which characters were alive or dead at the time, as Transformers: The Movie had not yet been released in Japan. This uncertainty may have been compounded by the storyboarding note above. It's also possible that, given his valuable capacities and given the existence of machinery able to fully revive a deceased robot(unveiled during Transformers:Headmasters) , Wheeljack had been rebuilt and existed anew in the years between the end of Transformers: The Headmasters and Transformers: Victory.

额。。。了解。。。
Wheeljack, along with Perceptor and Minerva were called upon to save God Ginrai, who they converted into Victory Leo. The general explanation for this error (and similar ones perpetrated with other characters in the earlier series, Transformers: Headmasters) is that the Japanese animators and writers were not fully aware of which characters were alive or dead at the time, as Transformers: The Movie had not yet been released in Japan.
如你所说：胜利之斗争中和米诺娃、感知器组成医疗小组救助重伤的超神迅雷，展开“胜利计划”。由于日本没有及时上映电影版，所以日本的编剧也搞不清楚谁死了谁没死。于是千斤顶又出现了。
不过英文中也没有说确认千斤顶本该已死啊。。。

In The Transformers: The Movie, set in the year 2005, Wheeljack was assigned to Autobot City on Earth. Wheeljack was killed in the invasion of Autobot City by Megatron’s forces, and his injured or possibly deceased body dragged to cover by Arcee. Interestingly, in the storyboards for the movie, it is Smokescreen, not Wheeljack, who lies dead, and Wheeljack himself can be seen alive amidst Devastator's attack. This may account for his anomalous appearance in Transformers: Victory.

。。。果然是强人，哪找的？

怎么又扯上烟幕了。。晕

WIKIPEDIA上就有。

3楼的回答真专业~~~